CNA Staff, Jun 18, 2024 / 17:08 pm (CNA).
A Texas doctor has been indicted for allegedly breaking federal law after he accessed patient records as part of an exposé into child transgender surgeries.
In 2022, Texas Children’s Hospital in Houston announced that it would cease performing transgender procedures on minors, citing concerns over “legal ramifications” after state Attorney General Ken Paxton said some of those medical procedures could be considered child abuse under state law.
Roughly a year later, journalist Christopher Rufo reported at City Journal that the hospital had “secretly continued to perform transgender medical interventions … on minor children.” Rufo cited “whistleblower documents” he obtained from inside the institution.
On Monday the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Texas said in a press release that Texas doctor Eithan Haim had been “indicted for obtaining protected individual health information for patients that were not under his care and without authorization.” Rufo previously identified Haim as the source of the documents.
Haim was set to make his first court appearance on Monday afternoon, the attorney’s office said. The doctor allegedly “obtained personal information including patient names, treatment codes, and the attending physician” from the Texas children’s hospital without authorization.
He “allegedly obtained this information under false pretenses and with intent to cause malicious harm to TCH,” the press release said.
If convicted, Haim “faces up to 10 years in federal prison and a $250,000 maximum possible fine,” the government said.
Texas has in recent years been at the forefront of the ongoing cultural and legal fight over transgender issues. The Biden administration in 2022 condemned the state policy whereby parents who facilitate “gender transition” medical treatments for children can be investigated for child abuse.
Gov. Greg Abbott in February of that year directed Texas Family and Protective Services to investigate certain procedures performed on children, including castration and hysterectomy, as well as puberty blockers and hormone treatments, as possible instances of child abuse.
Earlier this month, Paxton announced that the state had “won a major victory” against the Biden administration over the White House’s attempt to rewrite federal Title IX law to include transgender protections.
The government’s new education rules in part redefined “sex discrimination” under Title IX to include protections for “gender identity.” A judge subsequently ruled that the federal government “cannot regulate state educational institutions in this way without violating federal law.”
Texas “prevailed on behalf of the entire nation,” Paxton said in announcing the ruling.
The Texas Supreme Court, meanwhile, heard oral arguments in January in a challenge to the state’s ban on extreme transgender procedures performed on children. The outcome of that case is still pending.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
Bravo to this doctor for exposing these creepy ghouls who are turning small confused children into frankenstein experiments against the law. This privacy craze regarding medical records is something I have never understood. Very few medical records contain information which could be personally damaging to a person. Those would be items like abortion perhaps or sexually transmitted disease. Fewer still would have their lives impacted by publication of the information, like politicians. Otherwise I rather doubt anyone cares who has high blood pressure, diabetes or a toe fungus.What is more important here, privacy, or the fact that children below the age of consent are having their bodies illegally mutilated?
The alternative here is that the illict surgeries this doctor reported continued to be performed with impunity, against the law. This doctor has said he redacted the personal identifying information about the patients BEFORE making his report to the authorities. Therefore I dont see why he is being prosecuted for supposed privacy violations.
Bravo doctor, for doing the right thing !! What a pleasure to read about a man of integrity. I hope the hospital in question is fined a bundle of cash for allowing their facilities to be used in an illegal manner, and I hope the doctors performing these surgeries are stripped of their medical licenses.
There’s a good reason behind medical privacy laws but they can become an obstacle too.
“A Texas doctor has been indicted for allegedly breaking federal law after he accessed patient records as part of an exposé into child transgender surgeries.”
It certainly appears that the Federal Government is aiding and abetting acts of child abuse by their support of procedures that are being used not to restore health but to damage healthy bodies.
The tide is turning in the right direction thankfully but not quickly enough to save the children being experimented on today.
At least they’re safer in Texas now.