ACI Prensa Staff, Jun 29, 2024 / 08:00 am (CNA).
In the midst of the Hamas-Israel war in Gaza, the patriarchs and leaders of ancient Christian churches in Jerusalem have signed a joint document in which they denounce that four Israeli municipalities have sought to levy municipal taxes on church properties in violation of “centuries” of historical agreements.
The church leaders, including Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, Latin Catholic patriarch of Jerusalem, and Franciscan Father Francesco Patton, custos of the Holy Land, accuse local authorities of launching a “coordinated attack” against the Christian presence in the Holy Land.
“We believe these efforts represent a coordinated attack on the Christian presence in the Holy Land. At this time when the entire world, and in particular the Christian world, is constantly following the events in Israel, we find ourselves once again faced with an attempt by the authorities to expel the Christian presence from the Holy Land,” the leaders stated in a letter addressed to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, which has been quoted in various media such as The Times of Israel, Asia News, and UCA News.
In the June 23 letter, the church leaders expressed concern after receiving warning letters or notice of legal proceedings from four municipalities in Israel (Tel Aviv, Ramla, Nazareth, and Jerusalem) for alleged tax debts.
However, the leaders pointed out that “for centuries” church properties have had exemptions from municipal taxes according to the established status quo and that the churches have used this exemption to invest in services that benefit the state such as “schools, hospitals, nursing homes, and facilities for the disadvantaged.”
The leaders pointed out that the municipal actions are “tendentious” and contrary to the historical position of the churches and their relationship with the government, “violating the existing agreements and international commitments that ensure the rights of the churches.”
“It is an outrage that, specifically during such sensitive and complicated times when patience, compassion, unity in prayer, and hope should prevail, municipalities are opening cases against churches in courts and making threats. This constitutes contempt of our customs and that which is dear to us, while trampling the mutual respect that existed between us until this time,” the letter stated.
In an interview with the Associated Press, the Jerusalem Municipality stated that church authorities have not submitted the necessary applications for tax exemption in recent years.
They also said that, currently, “a dialogue is underway to collect debts” in connection with “commercial properties.”
The conflict over municipal taxes on church properties in Jerusalem dates back several years.
In 2018, the Jerusalem Municipality declared its intention to collect taxes on church properties not used as places of worship. This decision drew strong opposition from church leaders, who argued that the measure violated historical agreements and international commitments.
This story was first published by ACI Prensa, CNA’s Spanish-language news partner. It has been translated and adapted by CNA.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
Render to Caesar… seems pretty clear cut that for a Christian based religion there is a prior authoritative statement made by One person who owe all obedience to. Nothing wrong with taking a tax break offered but if it’s not offered then payment should be made.
I question the intent of this article, especially the headline. It sounds more like Israel would like to collect taxes on property used for purposes other than worship. How is that a “coordinated attack” on Christianity? “Render to Caesar what is Caesar’s…”.
At this point, with the corruption among Church authorities, I’m not automatically taking side with this one. I’d like to know the Jewish authorities side on this.
Ery disturbing. I am Catholic and a huge supporter of Israel. The Jews should pick their enemies with more care. Many if these places have no real parish support because they are historical places. True that a gift shop or lecture hall us not a church. But the gift shop provides funds to maintain the churches operation. And church aligned ideas would be conducted in the lecture hall. Are the towns really thus hard up for cash?? What municipal services do these sites receive that is such a burden?? Tons of Christians go to Israel every year to tour these places and drop a bundle in Jewish hotels restaurants and souvenir shops. Count me among them. If the churches close we wont be back. And they will make enemies of Christians who will resent their actions. Jewish authorities should think carefully if they want their tourist industry crippled. I dont think they need more enemies at this time.
According to some people, anyone outside their group are just cattle. Cattle of one breed aren’t necessarily guaranteed better treatment than cattle of another breed
I am not a fan of Israeli politics and I feel the USA owes Israel nothing. I want my tax dollars spent in the USA.
I’m a fan of sacred scripture Mr. Gerald & my Bible’s pretty clear that we owe Israel blessings, not curses.
You’re on the wrong website, bud. This is Catholic *World* Report, not Catholic *U.S.* Report.
Be careful of news published by CNA.
Sadly I’ve also found that to be the case from time to time, Deacon Edward.