Vatican City, Nov 21, 2024 / 12:30 pm (CNA).
The Vatican was not rocking around the Christmas tree on Thursday after a 95-foot Norway spruce from northern Italy became wreathed in controversy this fall.
An online petition posted to change.org in mid-October garnered over 53,000 signatures in protest of the evergreen being chopped down, arguing it contradicts Pope Francis’ promotion of protection for the environment.
Despite the opposition to its removal, the tree arrived as scheduled in St. Peter’s Square at 7 a.m. on Nov. 21 but was left to lie mysteriously on the truck bed well past sunset. As of publication, the spruce has still not been placed on its base.
The petition’s open letter to Pope Francis and Vatican and local Italian officials lamented the “solely consumerist practice of using live trees for ephemeral use, for mere advertising purposes and a few ridiculous selfies.”
It drew attention to the pope’s writings on care for creation and the importance of having respect for nature.
The letter, drafted by the wildlife protection association Bearsandothers, also argued that the Christmas tree is a pagan tradition that has nothing to do with Christ’s birth.
The petition also expressed opposition to the estimated 60,000 euros (about $63,000) of expenses incurred by the city of Ledro, in northern Italy, which donated the main Norway spruce and about 40 other trees to the Vatican.
“We are asking your help,” the letter said, “to send a strong message of reflection on the importance of valuing and respecting the role of the plant world in the anthropocentric era of increasingly dramatic climate anomalies.”
The Vatican said in a September press release that the nearly 100-foot spruce for St. Peter’s Square was selected “with respect to sustainability.” The trees chosen are more mature trees, it noted, arguing that their removal is in line with natural replacement.
The tree comes from nearby the small town of Ledro, which is close to Lake Garda and Lake Ledro in one of Italy’s northernmost provinces.
Smaller trees from the same area and decorated by the citizens of Ledro, and other towns in Italy, Germany, and the Czech Republic, will also be displayed in Vatican City buildings.
According to recent Vatican custom, the Christmas tree and a large Nativity scene displayed beside it will remain in St. Peter’s Square through Jan. 12, 2025, the feast of the Baptism of the Lord.
The tree-lighting ceremony and unveiling of the Nativity scene are scheduled for Dec. 7.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
Not long enough ago, an office kerfuffle erupted over the routine placement of a Christmas tree in the vestibule of a middle-ranking and already-woke government office where yours truly was employed.
My Gawd! What if someone from the public walked in and was, you know, offended?
So, a series of closed front-office meetings ensued, decorated with a series of follow-up staff indoctrination sessions. Then, “if not a tree, why not a wreath?” No. “If not a wreath, why not a single red poinsettia on the small coffee table?” Horrors! But, then “maybe a white poinsettia” because, as it was pointed out from on high, “a red poinsettia was still too laden with religious meaning.” Finally, the discredited front office chipped in for a simple wreath (no decorations, and purchased from a family-related marketer of things Christmas-y!), but my Gawd, this wall-hanging was to be referred to only as a “holiday wreath” and not a Christmas wreath.
Unseen Christmas stuff was still allowed, but only in staff cubicles. A pre-Christian Egyptian obelisk is okay for the Church’s modern-world cubicle, or dhimmi, or whatever–St. Peter’s Square. But not a Christmas tree. When an earlier pope was challenged about the atmospheric impacts of jet travel, the globe-trotting Pope John Paul II responded that “it’s a good way to evangelize.” But, be careful, too, about all those devotional candles!
So, multiculturally, the Chinese proverb about all things large and small: “The flapping of the wings of a butterfly can be felt on the other side of the world.” Plant a few small trees and call it a day.