Washington, D.C. Newsroom, Apr 19, 2024 / 15:30 pm (CNA).
President Joe Biden’s Department of Education issued new regulations on Friday, April 19, that prohibit discrimination based on a person’s “gender identity.”
The new rules, which will go into effect on Aug. 1, redefine the prohibition on sex discrimination for schools and education programs that receive federal funding — including K-12 schools and colleges and universities. Under the new interpretation of the Title IX protections, those rules now apply to any form of discrimination that is based on a person’s self-purported “gender identity.”
According to the executive summary of the Title IX revision, the changes are meant to “clarify that sex discrimination includes discrimination on the basis of sex stereotypes, sex characteristics, pregnancy or related conditions, sexual orientation, and gender identity.”
The summary further states that, except in certain situations, education institutions receiving federal funding cannot carry out “different treatment or separation on the basis of sex,” which includes a prohibition on any policy or practice that “prevents a person from participating in an education program or activity consistent with their gender identity.”
The new Title IX rules, however, do not have any direct rules related to transgender athletes in girls’ and women’s sports. About two dozen states have restricted participation in high school and college women’s sports to only biological women. It’s unclear whether these rules would violate the new interpretation of violations based on sex discrimination.
It’s also unclear how these rules would affect state laws that restrict bathroom and locker room access to a person based on his or her biological sex rather than gender identity or whether it would jeopardize free speech in relation to the use of a person’s preferred gender pronouns when those pronouns do not align with the person’s biological sex. The new rules did not clearly explain how the new definition would apply to such situations.
Alliance Defending Freedom Legal Counsel Rachel Rouleau expressed concerns that the Biden administration’s new definition of sex discrimination would negatively impact the rights of girls and women in education institutions.
“The Biden administration’s radical redefinition of sex turns back the clock on equal opportunity for women, threatens student safety and privacy, and undermines fairness in women’s sports,” Rouleau said in a statement on Friday.
“It is a slap in the face to women and girls who have fought long and hard for equal opportunities,” she added. “The administration continues to ignore biological reality, science, and common sense, and women are suffering as a result. The administration’s new regulation will have devastating consequences on the future of women’s sports, student privacy, and parental rights.”
Sarah Parshall Perry, a senior legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation and former senior counsel at the United States Department of Education, said in a statement that Title IX is being “manipulated” by “gender activists and woke politicos” through these actions.
“Under the new rule, girls and women will no longer have any sex-separated bathrooms, locker rooms, housing accommodations, or other educational programs,” Perry said. “Women’s sports are likely endangered too. Any education institution, including many private schools that receive even nominal federal funding, will be affected by this rule.”
Perry suggested that federal lawmakers should challenge the department’s actions “by clearly defining men and women” in legislation.
When Congress first added Title IX’s sex discrimination provisions into federal law in the 1970s, the goal was to give girls and women equal access to education. The law itself does not make reference to “gender identity.”
Other changes included in the administration’s rules related to Title IX include the prohibition on discriminating against a girl or a woman based on her being pregnant, her choosing to have an abortion, or her recovery from pregnancy. The revision also changes the process by which sexual assault allegations are handled.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
How sad for women’s sports. And for men’s sports as well. How will other men react to men (yes, they are biological men even if they decide to change their sex) who decide to “join the women’s team” or “compete against women” instead of striving to compete against their fellow men? And how many women will stick with a sport in which a biological man almost always prevails against them?
Why not create “co-ed” sports, in which men, women and any other “variety” of human compete TOGETHER as a team? This is what children often do–everyone plays!
There is a such a sport that’s been around since the 1950s. This sport is called synchronized skating, and it is done on ice. (It was formerly known as “precision team skating.) It was created in Ann Arbor, Michigan by Dr. Richard Porter, who noticed that female figure skaters often quit singles skating once they started growing too tall and “womanly” to achieve the double (and eventually triple and quad) jumps. Over the decades, synchronized skating (synchro) has evolved from a “marching band” style, to a “formation” sport that featured lines, blocks, circles, intersections, and wheels (pinwheels), to the current synchronized skating which features almost every element of figure skating including the “historical elements” (lines, blocks, etc.) along with ice dance elements, jumps (including double jumps!) and spins, lifts, and lots of speed and power! One skating official describes the sport as “beautiful danger”–collisions often result in serious injuries. And both MEN and WOMEN (or boys and girls at the younger levels) have always been allowed to compete together in synchronized skating!
Sadly, very few Americans have ever heard of, let alone seen the sport, as for some reason, the International Skating Union keeps hemming and hawing about giving it any genuine publicity or working to see it included in the Olympics, which provides the best visibility of all the sports. The IOC claims that there is not enough space for the teams in the hotels, and that the ice is already in use 24/7–oh, c’mon!– Cities build temporary hotels and venues for almost all the Olympic sports, and they could do the same for synchronized skating! The IOC admitted the immensely popular (at least in other countries than the U.S.A) sport of CURLING into the Olympics, which is also COED, and features a lot of older athletes who are hardly slim and trim or “the youth of the world”, as the IOC always says during the Olympic Opening Ceremonies!
I just think that if men want to compete with women, there are already opportunities that don’t pit men against women but instead, allow them to compete WITH women.