The latest instance of anti-religious prejudice in education is playing out in Vermont in Bishop v. Saunders. Ignoring three significant Supreme Court cases (highlighted below), Vermont lawmakers adopted a new statute excluding parents living in districts lacking their own secondary schools from participating in the state’s tuitioning program under which their boards pay the cost of sending children to public, but not faith-based, high schools.
Bishop challenges Vermont’s Act 73 as an unconstitutional limit on parental rights in revising its tuitioning program in a manner similar to Carson v. Makin, which the Supreme Court invalidated.
This column first reviews Act 73 and then offers analysis and reflections on why it is unlikely to withstand judicial scrutiny.
Bishop v. Saunders
On October 27, 2026, the highly successful Alliance Defending Freedom filed suit in the federal trial court in Vermont in Bishop v. Saunders on behalf of Carrie and Greg Bishop, plus their daughter, A.B., a high school senior.
Mrs. Bishop had to take “a second job to help pay for A.B.’s tuition this year. As a result, Carrie has had to spend more time away from home and less time with A.B., thus detrimentally impeding her ability to nurture and raise A.B.” This is because officials of their Barstow Unified Union School District refused to grant her coverage under the old law’s grandfather clause until she graduated from high school, even though she “fell into depression and struggled emotionally and spiritually” on having to leave the St. Joseph Catholic High School.
The Bishops challenged Act 73’s “relating to transforming Vermont’s education governance, quality, and finance systems” based on experiences their son had in public schools that “were growing increasingly more antagonistic and hostile to their [Christian] religious beliefs and much of what they taught contradicted what Carrie and Greg taught at home.” Consequently, although not Catholic, in order to “to fulfill their religious mandate to raise their daughters in-line with their Christian faith, the Bishops homeschooled their daughters through eighth grade and then sent all three to Mount St. Joseph…a Catholic high school serving grades 9–12 in Rutland, Vermont.”
A lengthy 147 pages, Act 73, which Governor Phil Scott signed into law on July 1, 2025, essentially disqualified all 15 of the state’s previously eligible faith-based schools from participating in its dual enrollment program.
The first of three new rules requires schools to be located where at least one district does not operate its own secondary school. Secondly, 25% of a school’s student body must have been publicly funded as of the 2023-24 year, thereby largely eliminating faith-based schools not allowed to take part until 2022 following the Supreme Court’s judgment in Carson v. Makin. Third, secondary schools had to meet minimum class sizes of 18, thereby penalizing smaller schools.
Under Vermont’s dual enrollment program, students in grades 11 and 12 are eligible to take up to two college courses at no cost to their families. Yet in imposing significant restrictions on faith-based schools, the law continues to permit 45 secular private schools to qualify to participate in the tuitioning program.
In challenging Act 73, the Bishop family raised three related claims. First, with the charge that it violated the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause by triggering strict scrutiny analysis because it is neither neutral nor generally applicable, and burdens their religious rights insofar as it treats comparable secular schools and their families better. When legislation or the actions of the government or public officials allegedly infringe on fundamental rights such as those identified explicitly in the Federal Constitution (including the free exercise of religion), they are subject to strict scrutiny, the most stringent form of judicial review. Under strict scrutiny, governmental classifications or actions are likely to fail unless they are based on compelling state interests achieved by the least restrictive means drawn with the most narrowly possible classifications rationally related to legitimate governmental purposes.
Second, the parents claimed that Act 73 violated their Fourteenth Amendment fundamental right to direct the upbringing of their children. The complaint acknowledged that this parental right is “perhaps the oldest of the fundamental liberty interests recognized” by the Supreme Court in such seminal ruling as 1925’s Pierce v. Society of Sisters wherein the Justices declared that “[t[he child is not the mere creature of the state; those who nurture him and direct his destiny have the right, coupled with the high duty, to recognize and prepare him for additional obligations.
Third, the Bishops emphasized that Act 73 violates their Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause rights by treating them and other parents whose children attend faith-based schools less fairly and equally than those who enroll their young in non-faith-based private institutions.
In order to compensate for these violations of their rights, the Bishops seek three preliminary and permanent injunctions. First, an order directing the board of their home school district to pay for A.B.’s tuition at Mount St. Joseph Academy for the entire 2026–2027 school year. Second, they seek injunctions directing state and local officials to permit A.B. to participate in the Dual Enrollment Program for the spring 2027 semester and pay her expenses. Third, they request enjoining the unconstitutional enforcement of Act 73’s Religious Exclusion so they can receive Town Tuition and Dual Enrollment funding.
The Bishop family also seeks a declaratory judgment that Act 73’s Religious Exclusion violates their rights under the Free and Equal Protection Clauses as well as their Fourteenth Amendment right to direct the upbringing and education of their children. Finally, the Bishops request nominal and compensatory damages, court costs and expenses, including reasonable attorney’s fees, and other relief to which the court deems they are entitled.
Analysis and reflections
Over the past nine years, starting with 2017’s Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia v. Comer, and followed by 2020’s Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue and 2022’s Carson v. Makin, the Supreme Court has made it clear that states cannot treat religious institutions and people of faith any differently than others in governmental programs offering generally available aid.
In light of the Supreme Court’s clear, unequivocal declarations ushering in what can aptly be described as establishing a blossoming of religious freedom in education, it is remarkable that Vermont officials revised their law on tuitioning in such a manner as essentially placing significant limits on, if not outright denying, the Federal Constitutional rights of parents interested in sending their children to faith-based schools.
At the risk of repetition because it is necessary to highlight their holdings, it is important to note that in Trinity Lutheran, the first of three opinions by Chief Justice Roberts, the Supreme Court found that Missouri could not deny a faith-based preschool the opportunity to participate in a program to purchase rubber playground surface materials made from recycled tires to enhance safety for children. Roberts emphasized that “the exclusion of Trinity Lutheran Church from a public benefit for which it is otherwise qualified, solely because it is a church, is odious to our Constitution all the same, and cannot stand.”
Three years later, in Espinoza, the Supreme Court invalidated Montana’s constitutional prohibition of public aid to “sectarian schools” as lacking a compelling governmental interest.
Roberts explained that because such assistance is permissible under the Establishment Clause, Montana’s contested no-aid provision impermissibly discriminated based on religious status. The Justices explained that while the disputed language sought to separate church and state more strictly than the Federal Constitution, it was invalid as lacking a compelling interest that could have satisfied strict scrutiny analysis.
Next, in Carson, the Supreme Court invalidated a Maine statute excluding “sectarian” schools from a program providing tuition assistance to parents in districts lacking their own secondary schools. Roberts reasoned that the law violated the Free Exercise Clause because it was neither neutral toward religion nor did it afford parents the opportunity to send their children to the schools of their choice.
Returning to the situation in Vermont, despite the Supreme Court’s insistence that jurisdictions treat faith-based schools and the parents who send their children to them fairly and equitably, state officials there have attempted an end-around by revising Act 73 in such a manner as blatantly continuing to ignore their First and Fourteenth Amendment rights. In so doing, Vermont legislators have tried to devise a novel approach to engage in religious discrimination in shutting out people of faith and their schools under the guise of what it will no doubt argue are neutral, objective criteria with no significant impact on families such as the Bishops.
Officials in Vermont essentially engaged in surreptitious religious discrimination against faith-based schools and families by using the three criteria of where schools are located, class size, and whether enough students attended institutions that were publicly funded, knowing that religious schools are unable to meet these standards for reasons identified above. In so doing, educational authorities in Vermont, along with the legislature, are penalizing taxpayers of faith whose property taxes cover the cost of public education for exercising their constitutional rights to religious freedom as well as to direct the upbringing of their young by imposing conditions they had to have known that the faith-based schools were unable to meet.
A good argument can be made that it would have been better for all in Vermont if these same state and local officials who devised the draconian conditions on participating in the tuitioning program, including its Dual Enrollment provisions, had spent the same amount of thought and energy in developing methods to advance the education of all the state’s students. Instead, these officials sought to engage in nothing short of legal casuistry by devising ways meant to essentially exclude parents of faith, their children, and the schools they attend from participating in a program open to all of the state’s residents.
Hopefully, the trial judge will correct the situation by complying with clear Supreme Court precedent, thus ensuring the rights of parents to direct the education and religious upbringing of their children. If and when the court rules, I will write a follow-up column.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


It says something about the culture when religious institutions are always having to sue the government to protect the rights of Catholic citizens. Unfortunately, when the Church finds itself in bed with secular agencies -especially for funding – this is inevitable. It’s doubtful the Amish have contracts with either State or Federal agencies.